Seasoning & Marinading Different Cuts
I won’t marinate the better cuts, because they will bring a flavor profile with them. The rib-eye and the New York Strip have a flavor; the filet’s a little weaker. For these, I season with salt and pepper at the beginning. I use a traditional kosher salt or a sea salt and fresh ground pepper. I make a 10:1 salt and pepper blend and just sprinkle it all over the steak.
When I’m looking to marinate something, I’ll drop to a flank steak or a tri-tip or one of the lesser cuts. Sometimes, I’ll marinate skirt steaks.
We’ve made a couple of marinades for the tri-tip that were really good. It’s basically an blend of 15 to 20 dried herbs, then we blended in shoyu (soy sauce). It gives it a really black look. The interesting thing is that it keeps the rub on the steak, much better than a dry rub stays on the steak.
Prepping
With beef, you want it to be room temperature before you start cooking it. By the time the steak is ready to be flipped, the top side is much hotter than room temperature. The goal is to simply get the heat to the middle of the meat, so the second side doesn’t need as much time as the front side.
I don’t use any oil on the meat -- I will on fish.
Grilling
There’s one tip that’s magic on the grill and this works with everything (fish, chicken, steak, etc.). I used to cook everything half and half, i.e. half the time on one side and half the time on the second side. Now I cook two thirds on one side and one third on the second side. I learned this from some chefs in San Francisco who were only cooking fish on one side.
In The Kitchen
The concept I use is the same in the kitchen as I would outside. If I am going to cook a steak in the kitchen, I would probably sear it in a skillet and finish it in a 350 degree F oven. I like the marking and the darkness on the outside, but I don’t like a heavy crust. If you cook it all the way in the pan, you are going to get a crust.
Take a steak that is 1 1/4 inch to 1 1/2 inch thick, give it a two to three minute sear on each side in a good hot pan, then move it into a pre-heated 350 degree F oven for 15 minutes and it’s a home run.
Let It Rest
For a regular steak, by the time you get it from the grill to the table and the rest of the meal is ready, that’s plenty of time to rest it -- so no more than 5 minutes. For a roast, you can let it rest for 15 minutes.
You also have to remember, when you take it off the grill, it’s going to continue cooking a little bit.